- Nov 18, 2026
- Shwetank Bhushan
Featured Articles
Love, Legacy and Omissions - The Missing Appendix
Dear Sonia Gandhi, congratulations on your book. 544 pages, and somehow still short on space. Alongside beaming photographs of handsome Rajiv Gandhi, you kept narrating how remarkable a statesman, an able administrator, a worthy leader, one of the best Prime Ministers, a visionary, and a loving husband he was... As a courtesy to your editors, here are the pages on his diverse qualities and numerous achievements that seem to have fallen out at the printer. You do call the 1984 #SikhPogrom shameful, and you do find people to blame: officials, a general, "sections" of the party. Around 3,000 Sikhs dead by the official count, many more by other estimates. The sentence that gets no room is your husband's own: "When a big tree falls, the earth shakes." Too long for 544 pages? Early December 1984. Thousands died in the world's worst industrial disaster, weeks into Rajiv ji's term. Union Carbide's Warren Anderson is arrested, bailed for Rs 25,000 and flown out of Bhopal on a government aircraft the same day. Who made that call has been disputed for forty years. A memoir written from inside the house was the perfect place to settle it. Did I skip that page? 1985: a divorced woman in her sixties wins a modest maintenance from the Supreme Court. 1986: Rajiv ji's government passes a law to undo it, and the fundamentalist clergy applaud. Your book reportedly notes that the Court later upheld that law. It skips the detail that the Court upheld it only by reading it to mean what #ShahBano had won. And in 1988, India became the first country to ban "The Satanic Verses": did that make the cut? May 1987, Meerut. PAC men pick up Muslim men from Hashimpura, shoot them and throw the bodies into canals. About 40 dead. A day later, Maliana: dozens more. Congress in Lucknow, Congress in Delhi. Hashimpura's convictions took 31 years. In Maliana, every accused was acquitted in 2023. Which chapter are these secular credentials printed in, ma'am? May 1987, Meerut. PAC men pick up Muslim men from Hashimpura, shoot them and throw the bodies into canals. About 40 dead. A day later, Maliana: dozens more. Congress in Lucknow, Congress in Delhi. Hashimpura's convictions took 31 years. In Maliana, every accused was acquitted in 2023. Which chapter are these secular credentials printed in, ma'am? October 1989. Two months of violence, 250 villages, about 1,000 dead, some 900 of them Muslims, 50,000 displaced. Congress in Patna, Congress in Delhi, Rajiv ji in the PM's chair. I am told your book has a great deal to say about communal forces. I was looking forward to the paragraph on this one. Alas! Bad editing. First, the Rajiv-Farooq accord. Then an election so overwhelmingly rigged that several of the young men who lost it, or guarded its ballot boxes, crossed the border and came back with guns. Everyone knew it was your loving husband who did it to favour his ally – NC and brought about the rise of the Mujahideen in the valley, which is still paying that bill. Surely worth one page? I gather the book describes how painful #Bofors was for Rajiv ji. Touching! Rs 64 crore in alleged kickbacks on the howitzer deal. A 1999 CBI chargesheet naming a former Prime Minister. And your dear family friend, Ottavio Quattrocchi, who left India in 1993 and never stood trial. Yes, the Delhi High Court cleared Rajiv ji of bribery in 2004. All the more reason to tell us about Mr Q. No? Sri Lanka, 1987-90. Tens of thousands of Indian soldiers were sent to keep a peace the LTTE had never agreed to, in terrain they were barely briefed on. About 1,200 never came home. The force left unthanked by either side. You write movingly of what the LTTE took from you in 1991. The families of those 1,200 would have liked a para too. 1991: India pledges its gold with barely $1 billion of reserves left. Late that year, the Swiss magazine Schweizer Illustrierte names Rajiv ji among leaders alleged to hold secret accounts, putting his at 2.5 billion francs. Never proven, I grant you. So did a rebuttal make it into the 544 pages? Page number, please. 1982: Your democrat husband publicly humiliates Andhra CM T. Anjaiah, calling him a "buffoon". Anjaiah is out within weeks; NTR sweeps the state a year later. 1987: announces his Foreign Secretary's replacement at a televised press conference, with A.P. Venkateswaran sitting in the hall. 1988: a Defamation Bill to muzzle the press, withdrawn only after journalists took to the streets. 1990: removes Karnataka CM Veerendra Patil while he is recovering from a stroke. "Belonging" is the right title. Everything belonged to the high command. Eh? Dear Mrs Sonia Gandhi, a memoir is allowed to be about love. But when the husband was Prime Minister, what is left out belongs to history too. For the second edition, may I suggest an appendix? The outline is above, free of charge. With respect to his memory, and to the dead of 1984, Bhopal, Meerut, Bhagalpur and Jaffna, this pic is worth being on the study table.- Nov 16, 2026
- Shubhi Malhotra & Dr Adityanjee
