- May 24, 2025
- Ramaharitha Pusarla
Featured Articles
Beneath the Facade of Trump's Peace Making
Responding to Trump’s claims of a ceasefire between India and Pakistan, in a rather provocative interview with Dutch Broadcaster NOS, EAM Jaishankar clarified, “The ceasefire was negotiated directly between India and Pakistan….We made one thing very clear to everybody who spoke to us, not just the United States, but to everyone, saying if the Pakistanis want to stop fighting, they need to tell us. We need to hear it from them. Their general has to call up our general and say this. And that is what happened”. He pointedly noted, “The US was in the United States”. Jaishankar’s statement is among the numerous clarifications and denials the government of India has issued as President Trump continued to double down on the India-Pakistan ceasefire. Trump, being Trump, as evident from his first term, is a compulsive credit hogger. He continues to strut around pompously, exaggerating his role in the India-Pakistan ceasefire even as India has been rebutting his claims both politically and diplomatically. Trump’s ceasefire statement on social media ahead of the Indian government’s formal announcement in the thick of the conflict baffled the political dispensation and Indians alike. While the Indian military inflicted a mighty blow on the Pakistani terrorist ecosystem, Trump’s hubristic claims of the American role and mediation have despoiled the sheen of Operation Sindoor’s huge success. India’s opportunistic opposition on a prowl to pounce on the political regime got a big stick to belittle the military’s big bang delivered to Pakistan. Having invested immense energies and tact to position himself as a peacemaker, Trump’s nugatory peace overtures to North Korea’s Kim Jong Un during his first term ended up as a damp squib. During his campaign, Trump promised to end the Russia-Ukraine war within 24 hours of taking charge. Four months into office, Trump declared, “This isn't my war. We got ourselves entangled in something we shouldn't have been involved in”. Terming the call with President Trump on May 21st, ‘excellent’, Putin agreed to ceasefire negotiations, but offered no timeline or verifiable pullback. In fact, Russian forces launched 100 drones on Ukraine the same day. While Trump omitted the issue of sanctions, Russia continued to persist with its hardline claims, made no compromises, but welcomed US efforts. Trump pushed the idea of increased economic cooperation between the US and Russia ahead of bilateral talks in Riyadh in March. Responding to Trump’s reset, Russia included investment manager Kirill Dmitriev in the delegation. The mineral deal with Ukraine has been the essential precondition for Trump for America’s continued support. Trump’s big proclamations on China ended as a dud missile due to Xi Jinping’s defiance. By imposing huge retaliatory tariffs, Xi forced America to blink first, from whopping 245% tariffs on some goods, countries have now settled on 30% tariffs. Trump vowed to bring about peace in the Middle East and end the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas. His team’s short-lived ceasefire ended up in a big failure, with Israel resuming attacks on Gaza after Hamas backed down on hostage release. The conflict continues to simmer in the Middle East. After his ‘peacemaker’ stance took a hit, he turned his attention away from Israel. Trump’s fetish for personal diplomacy and face-to-face interactions stems not from his aversion to conflicts but from his quest for deal-making steered by transactionalism. Unfortunately, his penchant for seeking a business opportunity is steadily overpowering his discretion in the complex geopolitical engagements. Trump, who signed a flurry of executive orders to combat anti-semitism, suddenly veered the track, voicing concerns over starvation in Gaza on the final day of his Gulf tour. Lest people miss the context, the $400 million Qatari jet made all the difference. Now, Trump is aggressively pushing for nuclear talks with Iran, much to the discomfort of Netanyahu, started direct negotiations with Hamas for American hostage release, lifted sanctions on Syria and recently bargained a temporary peace with Yemeni Houthis. Trump is keen that the world acknowledge his position as the leader of a superpower. He seeks an opportunity in every conflict to project America’s role. This was clearly evident in his repeated bluster about playing a role as mediator in the India-Pakistan conflict. Claiming that India has been fighting for 1000/ 1500 years with Pakistan he bragged about using the trade lever to stop the conflict, which was on the verge of going nuclear. In the process, he equated India and Pakistan all for the sake of optics. Trump’s equivocation of terror target, India, with terror perpetrator, Pakistan, has touched a raw nerve as it reminded New Delhi of the old entanglements. Trump’s repeated claims exposed his lack of understanding and his double-speak. In 2017, Trump vowed to “eradicate radical Islamic terrorism”, urged Muslim nations to “drive out terrorists”, and even barred citizens and refugees from seven Muslim countries over concerns of “terrorism”. Days into this second term, Trump approved the extradition of 26/11 accused Tahawwur Rana. The India-US Joint statement of February 13, 2025, stated, “recognising a shared desire to bring to justice those who would harm our citizens, the US announced that the extradition to India of Tahawwur Rana has been approved”. Days after the Pahalgam attacks, Trump announced US support for India in the fight against terrorism. In response to India’s strikes on terrorist camps in Pakistan, Trump reacted, “It’s a shame. We just heard about it, they have been fighting for a long time… I just hope it just ends quickly”. Four days later, Trump posted on Truth Social, “After a long night of talks mediated by the United States, I am pleased to announce that India and Pakistan have agreed to a FULL and IMMEDIATE CEASEFIRE. Congratulations to both Countries on using Common Sense and Great Intelligence”. In 2019, post Article-370 abrogation, on the sidelines of the G7 Summit, PM Modi categorically rejected “any scope of third-party mediation between India and Pakistan”. Trump’s repeated reiterations of false claims to hog in limelight were a rude shock. It betrayed India’s trust. India has refused to validate Trump’s claims on the ceasefire of Operation Sindoor, which is temporarily halted but not terminated. India is now doubling down on Pakistan by sending several multi-party delegations to various countries. Trump’s favourable statements about Pakistan, which are getting more repetitive, “Pakistan has got some excellent people, a really great leader,” have forced people to dig below the surface for answers. This eventually turned attention to a crypto deal signed between the Pakistan Crypto Council (PCC), set up a month ago, with World Liberty Foundation (WLF), a cryptocurrency firm. Trump’s family- his two sons and son-in-law Jared Kushner hold 75% of the stakes in the firm. It is co-chaired by Zachary Witkoff, the son of Trump’s special envoy Steve Witkoff. Pakistani Prime Minister and Army General Asim Munir was seen hosting them after the signing ceremony. Gentry Beach, a friend of Trump’s son Donald Trump Jr, a Trump associate who raised millions of dollars for Trump’s campaign, toured Pakistan, Bangladesh and Turkey in January. He is believed to have favoured investments in the mining sector and facilitated the crypto deal. In the thick of Operation Sindoor, the US unlocked the IMF bailout plan for Pakistan, facilitating the immediate release of $1 billion and approving a fresh loan of $1.4 billion. As India continues to intensify its campaign against Pakistan’s state-sponsored terrorism, Trump has recently appointed two known jihadists and sympathisers of Lashkar-e-Taiba, al-Qaeda and Hamas, Ismail Royer and Shaykh Hamza Yusuf, to the White House advisory board under the Religious Liberty Commission. Buoyed by Trump’s favours, Pakistan signed long-time Trump associates Javelin Associates, Keith Schiller, and George Sorial, the Trump Organisation’s compliance officer, to forge a long-term economic partnership and secure investments in mining. It is well known that countries lobby the US to influence its foreign policy for favourable gains and trade deals. However, Trump’s brazen whitewashing of Pakistani terrorism and re-hyphenation of India and Pakistan has dismayed New Delhi. Trump’s praise of Pakistan at the Union State address for handing over a terrorist while lashing out at India as ‘tariff King’ and authorisation of $397 million for F-16 maintenance, which is among the 243 exceptions made under an executive order that halted overseas funding, hasn’t escaped India’s notice. The drift has been steady. India was among the few countries to have diplomatically managed Trump’s trade deal, quietly absorbing his barbs. But this perceived red line and misadventurous blustering on India-Pakistan mediation has solidified India’s doubts of the US as an ‘unreliable partner’. Trump’s diplomatic cover fire to Pakistan is inexcusable on many counts as it betrays the trust of his own vote bank that has silently voiced concerns over Islamist radicalism. Additionally, Trump’s ‘big beautiful bill’, which proposes to impose 3.5% tax on outward remittances, his initial warning to Tim Cook, “I don’t want you building (manufacturing) in India” and threatening to impose 25% tax on iPhones made in India and other countries are ample indicators of his attempt to intimidate India. Putin has played down Trump, and Xi Jinping has defied him. Now, Trump is running down on India for some quick wins. Over eight decades, India has determinedly withstood America’s strong-arm tactics and asserted its strategic autonomy. However, Trump’s ruthless disregard of India’s insensitivities has sowed political distrust. Given the multi-dimensional cooperation of the Comprehensive Strategic Global Partnership between India and US, India has to now rework its engagement with Trump administration. With a strategic financial investment in Trump’s empire, Pakistan has now earned his backing. Implicitly, Trump expects Indian businesses to open their purse strings. While bureaucrats and analysts continue to parrot, ‘structural and systemic convergences between India and US are too deep’ to be undermined, the path to compromised American political systems clearly runs through lobbyist alleys. Value-based geopolitics is a thing of past; financial realism is what matters in Trump’s world.- May 22, 2025
- Viren S Doshi